Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi risks a military crisis if he does not reach an agreement with the powers negotiating a nuclear deal. AFP
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi risks a military crisis if he does not reach an agreement with the powers negotiating a nuclear deal. AFP
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi risks a military crisis if he does not reach an agreement with the powers negotiating a nuclear deal. AFP
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi risks a military crisis if he does not reach an agreement with the powers negotiating a nuclear deal. AFP

Plan B for Iran critical as nuclear talks face collapse


Thomas Harding
  • English
  • Arabic

The major powers negotiating for a new nuclear deal with Iran need to start preparing a Plan B as the talks approach collapse, a leading commentator said.

With the meetings for resurrecting the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action stalled it was critical for western powers, with China and Russia, to come up with a new approach involving new sanctions and intense diplomatic pressure, Kelsey Davenport said.

The urgency for a Plan B was growing with Iran’s “breakout time” for creating a nuclear weapon now reduced to potentially just a month to develop, Ms Davenport said, writing for Rusi, a London think thank.

“Given the proliferation risks posed by a collapse of the [nuclear deal], it is critical for the US and China, Russia, France, the UK and Germany to have a plan B if talks to restore the nuclear deal fail.”

It now appears the prospects for reviving the agreement are low, with Iran’s new president, Ebrahim Raisi, rejecting the progress made by his predecessor. The US has also said that the window for diplomacy to revive the deal will not remain open indefinitely.

Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps launch a barrage of rockets that could potentially be used if a nuclear crisis escalated. AFP
Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps launch a barrage of rockets that could potentially be used if a nuclear crisis escalated. AFP

No new deal could lead to a crisis, with fears Iran could resort to creating a nuclear weapon to increase its bargaining power. When the 2015 agreement was in place, it was thought that process would take about 12 months. It has since shrunk to between one and two months after Iran increased its stockpile of enriched uranium. Ironically, this was largely done in retaliation to former President Donald Trump brazenly pulling the US out of the deal in 2018.

Without the nuclear deal in place there is much less transparency on how far advanced Tehran's weapons programme is, leading to a potential miscalculation.

Both America and Israel have vowed to use air strikes if they believe Iran is close to creating a nuclear weapon.

“A larger-scale attack could push Tehran to consider abandoning its Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty commitments and pursuing nuclear weapons in order to deter further attacks,” wrote Ms Davenport, director for nonproliferation policy at the Arms Control Association.

She said that the US and Europe will now have to consider the “playbook that led to negotiations" on the nuclear deal that meant greater sanctions pressure and isolation, along with diplomacy.

But this would be difficult to achieve. “This strategy will be challenging and time-consuming to reconstitute even partially. The US is rightly criticised for sanctions overreach,” she wrote. “US credibility to lift sanctions was severely diminished by the Trump administration’s decision to withdraw ... while Iran was complying the deal.”

But there were also few areas left to “ratchet up economic pressure”.

Furthermore, Mr Raisi appears disinterested in good relations with the West. China and Russia might be supportive of greater international pressure but if it is perceived that the US causes the talks to collapse then “their [China and Russia] support for a sanctions-centric strategy is less likely”, Ms Davenport concluded in her paper, titled Preparing for Plan B with Iran.

Global institutions: BlackRock and KKR

US-based BlackRock is the world's largest asset manager, with $5.98 trillion of assets under management as of the end of last year. The New York firm run by Larry Fink provides investment management services to institutional clients and retail investors including governments, sovereign wealth funds, corporations, banks and charitable foundations around the world, through a variety of investment vehicles.

KKR & Co, or Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, is a global private equity and investment firm with around $195 billion of assets as of the end of last year. The New York-based firm, founded by Henry Kravis and George Roberts, invests in multiple alternative asset classes through direct or fund-to-fund investments with a particular focus on infrastructure, technology, healthcare, real estate and energy.

 

UPI facts

More than 2.2 million Indian tourists arrived in UAE in 2023
More than 3.5 million Indians reside in UAE
Indian tourists can make purchases in UAE using rupee accounts in India through QR-code-based UPI real-time payment systems
Indian residents in UAE can use their non-resident NRO and NRE accounts held in Indian banks linked to a UAE mobile number for UPI transactions

The biog

Age: 59

From: Giza Governorate, Egypt

Family: A daughter, two sons and wife

Favourite tree: Ghaf

Runner up favourite tree: Frankincense 

Favourite place on Sir Bani Yas Island: “I love all of Sir Bani Yas. Every spot of Sir Bani Yas, I love it.”

The specs: 2017 Dodge Ram 1500 Laramie Longhorn

Price, base / as tested: Dhxxx
Engine: 5.7L V8
Transmission: Eight-speed automatic
Power: 395hp @ 5,600rpm
Torque: 556Nm @ 3,950rpm
Fuel economy, combined: 12.7L / 100km

Updated: October 08, 2021, 2:34 PM`