Lessons from Somalia for the US's trouble in Sudan



Africa does not generally dominate the global news agenda, but that is about to change over the next three months.

The US and two of its close allies in Africa are facing challenges that could potentially lead to catastrophe. In the horn of Africa, the US-backed leadership in Somalia, the Transitional Federal Government, has failed to establish control over more than a few parts of the capital, Mogadishu, and the airport and sea port. It clings to this toehold thanks to the presence of 6,000 African peace-keeping troops, which are so far fighting off the al Qa'eda-linked militants of al Shebab.

To the west, the countdown has begun for an independence referendum in southern Sudan on January 9. If this vote goes ahead, it is all but certain that the people of the south will vote for independence, thus slicing off a large part of Sudan's territory, including much of its oil wealth. If the referendum fails to go ahead - quite likely, given the huge difficulties of organising it - or is contested, then a flare-up of the war which disfigured southern Sudan for most of the latter half of the 20th century is highly likely. Given how heavily armed both sides are, the fighting would be even worse. The people of the south believe they have the backing of the Washington and the American people to create the first new state in Africa for 20 years. They should be a little cautious.

The two flashpoints are united by one common thread: the impossibility of Washington to protect its clients in places where it is cannot put boots on the ground. After the ignominious retreat of the US military from Somalia following a 1993 battle portrayed in the movie Black Hawk Down, Barack Obama cannot even think of sending troops back to Mogadishu. As for Sudan, the area is so vast and so remote that any sensible general would hesitate to deploy. It would be a gift to America's enemies, who would see it as Washington conspiring to lop off another oil-rich chunk of the Arab nation, following the near secession of Iraqi Kurdistan.

The only hope for Sudan is that some lessons can be learned from Somalia. The transitional government, under President Sharif Ahmed, was brought into Mogadishu from exile in Kenya after the Ethiopian army, with US support, removed the Islamic Courts Union, which appeared to be establishing some stable Islamist form of government. The transitional government is dismissed by its enemies as a bunch of corrupt puppets. Unable to control the territory or bring services to the people, it has only one achievement to its name: inspiring and giving cohesion to the Al Shebab fighters.

Already, the Shebab-controlled areas of Somalia are a training ground and global hub for jihadists, including those from countries with large Somali diasporas, such as the US, Canada, Britain, Italy and Sweden. Jonathan Evans, the director of Britain's security service, MI5, predicts that Shebab-controlled Somalia will take over from Pakistan as the main source of terrorist threat. One body of opinion holds that the original sin in this mess was Washington's decision to remove the Islamic Courts Union and not to engage with it. But the real issue now is how to stop the country from deteriorating further.

One suggestion is "constructive disengagement", a seductive diplomatic term for an arm's length involvement in a country which Washington clearly does not understand. It means: stop backing the transitional government; stop trying to build a government; negotiate aid deliveries with whoever is in power locally; use all of America's surveillance capacity to keep an eye on the place; and try to engage with clans who reject the Taliban-isation of Somalia under al Shebab.

Opponents from the American security complex say it could make a bad situation worse, empowering al Shebab to take over the two relatively stable parts of Somalia, Somaliland and Puntland. Politically, such a course would be poison for Mr Obama, who would open himself up to the charge that he handed the whole country over to terrorists. Washington is hedging its bets. The State Department has announced a new twin-track approach, involving closer relations with Puntland and Somaliland, which now appear as more realistic springboards for a counter-offensive against al Shebab than the government controlling a few blocks of the city of Mogadishu. But this is a holding operation: Mr Obama has no cards to play now.

The clear lesson is not to create another African puppet in southern Sudan which it cannot protect. This is proving hard, as there is a strong groundswell of support in America for the southern Sudanese. In America, the conflict is portrayed is simplistic terms - northern Muslims Arabs oppressing the Africans in the south, with President Omar Bashir, who is already facing charges of genocide in Darfur, cast as the evil genius. So the liberal interventionists, such as the actor George Clooney, will be satisfied with nothing less than an independent state. Hillary Clinton, the US Secretary of State, has already called on Khartoum to accept the "inevitable" secession of the south, despite the fears of the Arab League and the African Union.

But it is far from certain that the vote can take place. The referendum can hardly be held without a solution to the fate of Abyei, a contested area producing most of Sudan's oil, which has been promised its own referendum, though its borders and who can vote are still subject to dispute. As the tide of opinion in the south is moving in favour of secession, in the event of the vote being cancelled there will be pressure from the southern leader, Salva Kiir, to made a unilateral declaration of independence.

Independence, in this case, is more virtual than real. This is one of the least developed parts of the habitable globe which cannot survive without massive handouts of food aid. The weakness of the south provides scope for diplomatic pressure, while the desire of President Bashir to escape the charge of genocide provides scope for the US to provide some diplomatic carrots. The oil revenues could be divided in some way.

What is most important is to avoid the Somali precedent, where America's prestige is tied to the success of a leadership which manifestly cannot stand on his own two feet.

Our legal columnist

Name: Yousef Al Bahar

Advocate at Al Bahar & Associate Advocates and Legal Consultants, established in 1994

Education: Mr Al Bahar was born in 1979 and graduated in 2008 from the Judicial Institute. He took after his father, who was one of the first Emirati lawyers

Election pledges on migration

CDU: "Now is the time to control the German borders and enforce strict border rejections" 

SPD: "Border closures and blanket rejections at internal borders contradict the spirit of a common area of freedom" 

Ms Yang's top tips for parents new to the UAE
  1. Join parent networks
  2. Look beyond school fees
  3. Keep an open mind
The specs: 2018 Chevrolet Trailblazer

Price, base / as tested Dh99,000 / Dh132,000

Engine 3.6L V6

Transmission: Six-speed automatic

Power 275hp @ 6,000rpm

Torque 350Nm @ 3,700rpm

Fuel economy combined 12.2L / 100km

The biog

Favourite films: Casablanca and Lawrence of Arabia

Favourite books: Start with Why by Simon Sinek and Good to be Great by Jim Collins

Favourite dish: Grilled fish

Inspiration: Sheikh Zayed's visionary leadership taught me to embrace new challenges.

Specs

Engine: Duel electric motors
Power: 659hp
Torque: 1075Nm
On sale: Available for pre-order now
Price: On request

UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Anxiety and work stress major factors

Anxiety, work stress and social isolation are all factors in the recogised rise in mental health problems.

A study UAE Ministry of Health researchers published in the summer also cited struggles with weight and illnesses as major contributors.

Its authors analysed a dozen separate UAE studies between 2007 and 2017. Prevalence was often higher in university students, women and in people on low incomes.

One showed 28 per cent of female students at a Dubai university reported symptoms linked to depression. Another in Al Ain found 22.2 per cent of students had depressive symptoms - five times the global average.

It said the country has made strides to address mental health problems but said: “Our review highlights the overall prevalence of depressive symptoms and depression, which may long have been overlooked."

Prof Samir Al Adawi, of the department of behavioural medicine at Sultan Qaboos University in Oman, who was not involved in the study but is a recognised expert in the Gulf, said how mental health is discussed varies significantly between cultures and nationalities.

“The problem we have in the Gulf is the cross-cultural differences and how people articulate emotional distress," said Prof Al Adawi. 

“Someone will say that I have physical complaints rather than emotional complaints. This is the major problem with any discussion around depression."

Daniel Bardsley

About Proto21

Date started: May 2018
Founder: Pir Arkam
Based: Dubai
Sector: Additive manufacturing (aka, 3D printing)
Staff: 18
Funding: Invested, supported and partnered by Joseph Group

The specs
 
Engine: 3.0-litre six-cylinder turbo
Power: 398hp from 5,250rpm
Torque: 580Nm at 1,900-4,800rpm
Transmission: Eight-speed auto
Fuel economy, combined: 6.5L/100km
On sale: December
Price: From Dh330,000 (estimate)
Specs

Engine: 51.5kW electric motor

Range: 400km

Power: 134bhp

Torque: 175Nm

Price: From Dh98,800

Available: Now

Padmaavat

Director: Sanjay Leela Bhansali

Starring: Ranveer Singh, Deepika Padukone, Shahid Kapoor, Jim Sarbh

3.5/5

Singham Again

Director: Rohit Shetty

Stars: Ajay Devgn, Kareena Kapoor Khan, Ranveer Singh, Akshay Kumar, Tiger Shroff, Deepika Padukone

Rating: 3/5

Multitasking pays off for money goals

Tackling money goals one at a time cost financial literacy expert Barbara O'Neill at least $1 million.

That's how much Ms O'Neill, a distinguished professor at Rutgers University in the US, figures she lost by starting saving for retirement only after she had created an emergency fund, bought a car with cash and purchased a home.

"I tell students that eventually, 30 years later, I hit the million-dollar mark, but I could've had $2 million," Ms O'Neill says.

Too often, financial experts say, people want to attack their money goals one at a time: "As soon as I pay off my credit card debt, then I'll start saving for a home," or, "As soon as I pay off my student loan debt, then I'll start saving for retirement"."

People do not realise how costly the words "as soon as" can be. Paying off debt is a worthy goal, but it should not come at the expense of other goals, particularly saving for retirement. The sooner money is contributed, the longer it can benefit from compounded returns. Compounded returns are when your investment gains earn their own gains, which can dramatically increase your balances over time.

"By putting off saving for the future, you are really inhibiting yourself from benefiting from that wonderful magic," says Kimberly Zimmerman Rand , an accredited financial counsellor and principal at Dragonfly Financial Solutions in Boston. "If you can start saving today ... you are going to have a lot more five years from now than if you decide to pay off debt for three years and start saving in year four."