Mathys Tel N/A
The youngster was active and hungry but ultimately, didn’t make too much of an impact. PA
Andre Onana 6/10
MAN UNITED RATINGS: Tonight wasn’t the problem. Conceding 14 in the first five games was, though United wouldn’t have won a single game had he not made important saves against Copenhagen. Could do litShow more
Diogo Dalot 5/10
Aggressively got forward from the start and better in defending. Shifted to left-back for the second half. Ran through in one limp 72nd minute attack. Getty
Raphael Varane 6/10
Recalled for a huge game and twice headed Bayern crosses away after 12 minutes. Calm at this level, though United’s man-marking defenders makes the team easy to play against. He should’ve been a key pShow more
Harry Maguire 7/10
Intercepted an 18th minute Bayern attack and was doing fine until he pulled his groin on 39 minutes. Applauded by supporters as he left the field. More injury misery for United as things go from bad tShow more
Luke Shaw 7/10
United are better with him as left-back. His rocket shot was punched away by Neuer on 23 minutes – yes, one United player did have an effort on goal. Coman was a handful for him, too. Off injured at hShow more
Sofyan Amrabat 5/10
Neat, tidy and effective as he covered his spaces well. That was the first half. Nowhere for Sane’s goal in the second. Booked. EPA
Scott McTominay 5/10
Peripheral. Just 43 touches. Not that United were effective in possession. Getty
Antony 6/10
Hit a shot well over on four minutes, then surged forward minutes later, nutmegging Kim Min-jae. Won the ball back to stop a 31st minute Bayern attack. Booked. AP
Bruno Fernandes 6/10
More shots than any United player, not that any went near the goal. Defended well, but had a fine chance on 48 minutes, which he wasted. The agonised expression on manager Erk ten Hag’s face said it aShow more
Alejandro Garnacho 6/10
Bright – and busy – start against Sane. Pressed hard, full of energy, held onto the ball too much at times. AP
Rasmus Hojlund 5 /10
Isolated. Worked hard. A rural rail line has better service on a Sunday. Onana had double the number of touches as Hojlund. Getty
Jonny Evans 6/10
SUBS: (On for Maguire, 39') - Did nothing wrong. Getty
Aaron Wan-Bissaka 7/10
(On for Shaw, 45') - Straight to right-back as a half-time introduction, where he cut a lovely ball back to Fernandes on 48 minutes and cut out a Bayern attack on 52 minutes. Getty
Hannibal Mejbri 6/10
(On for Garnacho, 73') - Worked hard. Getty
Facundo Pellistri 6/10
(On for Antony, 73') - Like the rest of his teammates, he failed to get much out of Bayern. Getty
Kobbie Mainoo N/A
(On for Varane, 79') - Champions League experience for the youngster. PA
Manuel Neuer 7/10
BAYERN MUNICH RATINGS: The eccentric keeper barely had anything to do on an evening in which the Red Devils struggled in front of goal. AFP
Alphonso Davies 7/10
The Canadian’s pace was evident for all to see and while he wasn’t the main attraction , he held his own down the left flank. Getty
Kim Min-jae 8/10
Kim’s no-nonsense approach led to him saving the day for Bayern at the back with some really crucial interceptions and tackles. Getty
Dayot Upamecano 8/10
Had good spatial awareness, a strong physical presence and made some key challenges in a really strong outing. Getty
Noussair Mazraoui 6/10
Had a solid enough display in the first half but was perhaps one of the weaker links, as evidenced by his substitution at half time. AP
Leon Goretzka 7/10
Fought hard in the lead up to Coman's goal and kept things at a calm pace in the middle of the park. AP
Joshua Kimmich 5/10
This was a game to forget for the midfielder as he was sloppy in possession, poor in attack and generally far too conservative. AFP
Leroy Sane 6/10
The trickster needs to improve in the final third after a game where he was outshone by those around him. PA
Jamal Musiala 8/10
He carried the ball confidently, carved through the United defence on several occasions and never stopped chasing the hosts down. PA
Kingsley Coman 9/10
It was a night to remember for Coman as his exceptional passing ability was matched by a composed finish to win the game. Getty
Harry Kane 8/10
Bayern’s talisman held the ball up well, had good distribution and provided the assist for Coman’s goal. Getty
Konrad Laimer 7/10
SUBS: It was an effective display from Laimer as he kept things simple, rarely put a foot wrong and looked pretty efficient at the back. PA
Thomas Muller 7/10
The savvy forward showed great movement off the ball as always, and his veteran instincts led to some positive passages of play. Getty
Raphaël Guerreiro N/A
Only had a few minutes on the pitch as he helped Bayern ride things out and pick up all three points. PAMathys Tel N/A
The youngster was active and hungry but ultimately, didn’t make too much of an impact. PAAndre Onana 6/10
MAN UNITED RATINGS: Tonight wasn’t the problem. Conceding 14 in the first five games was, though United wouldn’t have won a single game had he not made important saves against Copenhagen. Could do litShow moreDiogo Dalot 5/10
Aggressively got forward from the start and better in defending. Shifted to left-back for the second half. Ran through in one limp 72nd minute attack. GettyRaphael Varane 6/10
Recalled for a huge game and twice headed Bayern crosses away after 12 minutes. Calm at this level, though United’s man-marking defenders makes the team easy to play against. He should’ve been a key pShow moreHarry Maguire 7/10
Intercepted an 18th minute Bayern attack and was doing fine until he pulled his groin on 39 minutes. Applauded by supporters as he left the field. More injury misery for United as things go from bad tShow moreLuke Shaw 7/10
United are better with him as left-back. His rocket shot was punched away by Neuer on 23 minutes – yes, one United player did have an effort on goal. Coman was a handful for him, too. Off injured at hShow moreSofyan Amrabat 5/10
Neat, tidy and effective as he covered his spaces well. That was the first half. Nowhere for Sane’s goal in the second. Booked. EPAScott McTominay 5/10
Peripheral. Just 43 touches. Not that United were effective in possession. GettyAntony 6/10
Hit a shot well over on four minutes, then surged forward minutes later, nutmegging Kim Min-jae. Won the ball back to stop a 31st minute Bayern attack. Booked. APBruno Fernandes 6/10
More shots than any United player, not that any went near the goal. Defended well, but had a fine chance on 48 minutes, which he wasted. The agonised expression on manager Erk ten Hag’s face said it aShow moreAlejandro Garnacho 6/10
Bright – and busy – start against Sane. Pressed hard, full of energy, held onto the ball too much at times. APRasmus Hojlund 5 /10
Isolated. Worked hard. A rural rail line has better service on a Sunday. Onana had double the number of touches as Hojlund. GettyJonny Evans 6/10
SUBS: (On for Maguire, 39') - Did nothing wrong. GettyAaron Wan-Bissaka 7/10
(On for Shaw, 45') - Straight to right-back as a half-time introduction, where he cut a lovely ball back to Fernandes on 48 minutes and cut out a Bayern attack on 52 minutes. GettyHannibal Mejbri 6/10
(On for Garnacho, 73') - Worked hard. GettyFacundo Pellistri 6/10
(On for Antony, 73') - Like the rest of his teammates, he failed to get much out of Bayern. GettyKobbie Mainoo N/A
(On for Varane, 79') - Champions League experience for the youngster. PAManuel Neuer 7/10
BAYERN MUNICH RATINGS: The eccentric keeper barely had anything to do on an evening in which the Red Devils struggled in front of goal. AFPAlphonso Davies 7/10
The Canadian’s pace was evident for all to see and while he wasn’t the main attraction , he held his own down the left flank. GettyKim Min-jae 8/10
Kim’s no-nonsense approach led to him saving the day for Bayern at the back with some really crucial interceptions and tackles. GettyDayot Upamecano 8/10
Had good spatial awareness, a strong physical presence and made some key challenges in a really strong outing. GettyNoussair Mazraoui 6/10
Had a solid enough display in the first half but was perhaps one of the weaker links, as evidenced by his substitution at half time. APLeon Goretzka 7/10
Fought hard in the lead up to Coman's goal and kept things at a calm pace in the middle of the park. APJoshua Kimmich 5/10
This was a game to forget for the midfielder as he was sloppy in possession, poor in attack and generally far too conservative. AFPLeroy Sane 6/10
The trickster needs to improve in the final third after a game where he was outshone by those around him. PAJamal Musiala 8/10
He carried the ball confidently, carved through the United defence on several occasions and never stopped chasing the hosts down. PAKingsley Coman 9/10
It was a night to remember for Coman as his exceptional passing ability was matched by a composed finish to win the game. GettyHarry Kane 8/10
Bayern’s talisman held the ball up well, had good distribution and provided the assist for Coman’s goal. GettyKonrad Laimer 7/10
SUBS: It was an effective display from Laimer as he kept things simple, rarely put a foot wrong and looked pretty efficient at the back. PAThomas Muller 7/10
The savvy forward showed great movement off the ball as always, and his veteran instincts led to some positive passages of play. GettyRaphaël Guerreiro N/A
Only had a few minutes on the pitch as he helped Bayern ride things out and pick up all three points. PAMathys Tel N/A
The youngster was active and hungry but ultimately, didn’t make too much of an impact. PAManchester United v Bayern Munich ratings: Hojlund 5, Antony 6; Coman 9, Kane 8
Coman's 70th-minute goal seals Bayern's place at top of Champions League Group A as United crash out of Europe
Harry Kettle
December 13, 2023