John Lewis has underperformed for much of the past decade. PA
John Lewis has underperformed for much of the past decade. PA
John Lewis has underperformed for much of the past decade. PA
John Lewis has underperformed for much of the past decade. PA


John Lewis bonus payouts built on crippling debts but salad days are gone


  • English
  • Arabic

July 04, 2023

We've just had Employee Ownership Day in the UK. I know, me neither.

Businesses belonging to their workers is, though, a hot topic again. At the last count there were 1,300 employee-owned businesses in the UK, from Arup, the design and engineering firm, to Zetter, the recruitment agency.

Increasingly, staff having a stake in the firm is seen as appealing. Employee-ownership has more than doubled in the past three years. The top 50 such businesses produced revenue of £21.7 billion last year; at nine in 10 employee-owned businesses the staff have a say in decisions on the working conditions; 85 per cent have some or a lot of say in new working methods.

For that information I’m grateful to Dame Sharon White, chairwoman of the John Lewis Partnership, best-known of the employee-owned organisations, operator of the John Lewis department stores and Waitrose supermarket chain, famed for middle-class staples quinoa and rocket salads. White, a former senior civil servant and therefore not a time-served retailer – something held against her by her critics – has turned into something of an evangelist for her sector.

She marked its national celebration day (seriously, it exists) by highlighting the surge in industrial strife in the past year and the damage caused to the economy through strikes and go-slows, and asking: “Is there an alternative to industrial action? If workers felt they had more of a stake – or greater sense of ownership – in the business or the public service they were providing, there could be fewer disputes and more limited industrial action.”

In a country that lost 3.7 million working days to strikes last year, not only in the public services, in schools, railways, hospitals, but also in private enterprises, such as Amazon and Heathrow, anything that can bring that total down and instil harmony and keep things running, is welcome. Doubtless, they would work harder, too.

This week marks the 75th birthday of the NHS, and it was not that long ago, during the David Cameron-Nick Clegg coalition era, that government thoughts turned to restructuring the health service along the lines of the mutual model. Those arguments have resurfaced, as in the intervening period, the NHS’s problems have worsened and we are facing a septuagenarian structure that is no longer fit for purpose.

John Lewis employees have had their bonuses slashed as the company struggles to turn a profit. Getty Images
John Lewis employees have had their bonuses slashed as the company struggles to turn a profit. Getty Images

Back then, the example that was upheld repeatedly by ministers, policy-formers and the media was John Lewis. It was before White’s time, but her organisation was seen as promising nirvana, producing outstanding performance while properly rewarding fulfilled workers or ‘partners’. Each year they would receive an annual bonus, the announcement of which became a media event.

The two went together: the production of great results by staff who had a stake in the business. There was a third benefit: customers were also delighted, marvelling at the care and level of service afforded by John Lewis employees who seemed to go further than managers and sales assistants elsewhere.

Since then, it’s not just the NHS that has experienced decline. John Lewis made a loss of £243 million in 2022 and its staff did not receive a bonus.

White, who took charge in 2020, has been taking drastic action, closing 16 John Lewis stores, trimming 13 Waitrose branches and cutting head office costs. Among the casualties is the “Never Knowingly Undersold” price promise, deemed out-of-date in today’s online, shop-around environment. Another is the Partnership’s very own golf course (who knew) at Maidenhead, in Berkshire.

John Lewis fell victim to the switch to online and was also hit by rising costs at its extra-large high street sites. Waitrose, meanwhile, was caught, stuck between low prices at the bottom of the market, sparked by the budget invaders Aldi and Lidl and a competing Tesco, Morrison’s and Sainsbury, and at the top end, a revitalised Marks & Spencer.

White found that democracy has its downside, as her fellow partners made their feelings known about her leadership. In May this year, almost a quarter of staff representatives voted against her in a confidence ballot. Of the 55 members of the staff council who voted, 24 per cent were against White continuing to head the business, while 92 per cent said they did not support her performance over the past year.

John Lewis's Dame Sharon White at an investiture ceremony at Windsor Castle. PA
John Lewis's Dame Sharon White at an investiture ceremony at Windsor Castle. PA

What’s telling, though, is to revisit those glory years when politicians, commentators, could not get enough of John Lewis. From 2000 to 2015, the business expanded rapidly. John Lewis grew its stores from 25 to 43, Waitrose went from 126 to 336 branches, the number of employees or partners climbed from 40,000 to 90,000. Sales more than doubled, from £4bn to £10.8bn, but profits stayed the same as margins were hit by Aldi and Lidl, and the growth in online shopping.

Profit per partner fell substantially, but significantly, over that same period, the Partnership bonus averaged 14 per cent. At the same time, to pay for the expansion, the organisation borrowed heavily, with net debt rising from £1bn to £3.7bn.

John Lewis, then, was effectively running on, or close to, empty but the partners were still being paid a hefty bonus. In effect, the organisation was borrowing to meet those staff payouts.

John Lewis, then, was effectively running on, or close to, empty but the partners were still being paid a hefty bonus. In effect, the organisation was borrowing to meet those staff pay-outs

They were content, and because the workers were cheery, there was not a pipsqueak of complaint anywhere. The John Lewis Partnership was widely lauded for its brilliance.

White has injected a dose of realism. On her watch, bonuses will only be paid where they’re affordable. She’s taken out £300 million in costs with another £600 million still to go. Borrowings are down. Sustained profitability, White insists, is returning.

But clearly, not all her colleagues are enthused, hence the backlash. Questions remain too about the level of funding needed to execute her plan to refurbish the stores and boost IT – there has been talk of transforming some of the department stores, changing them to part-retail, part-apartments.

White is reluctant to borrow and she can’t pursue the other traditional route of corporate fund-raising, of going to external investors, since she does not have any. White has indicated she would countenance altering the business model, to seek funding from outside investors. She could reduce employee ownership from 100 per cent to 75 per cent, without destroying the overall premise. Employees would keep control, but with 25 per cent held externally.

Clearly, it’s now apparent, John Lewis was not as marvellous as all that. Nevertheless, as models go, employee ownership is not bad either. Anything, to reduce our twin diseases of strikes and low productivity.

Central%20Bank's%20push%20for%20a%20robust%20financial%20infrastructure
%3Cul%3E%0A%3Cli%3ECBDC%20real-value%20pilot%20held%20with%20three%20partner%20institutions%26nbsp%3B%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli%3EPreparing%20buy%20now%2C%20pay%20later%20regulations%26nbsp%3B%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli%3EPreparing%20for%20the%202023%20launch%20of%20the%20domestic%20card%20initiative%26nbsp%3B%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3Cli%3EPhase%20one%20of%20the%20Financial%20Infrastructure%20Transformation%20(FiT)%20completed%3C%2Fli%3E%0A%3C%2Ful%3E%0A
Key facilities
  • Olympic-size swimming pool with a split bulkhead for multi-use configurations, including water polo and 50m/25m training lanes
  • Premier League-standard football pitch
  • 400m Olympic running track
  • NBA-spec basketball court with auditorium
  • 600-seat auditorium
  • Spaces for historical and cultural exploration
  • An elevated football field that doubles as a helipad
  • Specialist robotics and science laboratories
  • AR and VR-enabled learning centres
  • Disruption Lab and Research Centre for developing entrepreneurial skills
What drives subscription retailing?

Once the domain of newspaper home deliveries, subscription model retailing has combined with e-commerce to permeate myriad products and services.

The concept has grown tremendously around the world and is forecast to thrive further, according to UnivDatos Market Insights’ report on recent and predicted trends in the sector.

The global subscription e-commerce market was valued at $13.2 billion (Dh48.5bn) in 2018. It is forecast to touch $478.2bn in 2025, and include the entertainment, fitness, food, cosmetics, baby care and fashion sectors.

The report says subscription-based services currently constitute “a small trend within e-commerce”. The US hosts almost 70 per cent of recurring plan firms, including leaders Dollar Shave Club, Hello Fresh and Netflix. Walmart and Sephora are among longer established retailers entering the space.

UnivDatos cites younger and affluent urbanites as prime subscription targets, with women currently the largest share of end-users.

That’s expected to remain unchanged until 2025, when women will represent a $246.6bn market share, owing to increasing numbers of start-ups targeting women.

Personal care and beauty occupy the largest chunk of the worldwide subscription e-commerce market, with changing lifestyles, work schedules, customisation and convenience among the chief future drivers.

Who is Tim-Berners Lee?

Sir Tim Berners-Lee was born in London in a household of mathematicians and computer scientists. Both his mother, Mary Lee, and father, Conway, were early computer scientists who worked on the Ferranti 1 - the world's first commercially-available, general purpose digital computer. Sir Tim studied Physics at the University of Oxford and held a series of roles developing code and building software before moving to Switzerland to work for Cern, the European Particle Physics laboratory. He developed the worldwide web code as a side project in 1989 as a global information-sharing system. After releasing the first web code in 1991, Cern made it open and free for all to use. Sir Tim now campaigns for initiatives to make sure the web remains open and accessible to all.

From Europe to the Middle East, economic success brings wealth - and lifestyle diseases

A rise in obesity figures and the need for more public spending is a familiar trend in the developing world as western lifestyles are adopted.

One in five deaths around the world is now caused by bad diet, with obesity the fastest growing global risk. A high body mass index is also the top cause of metabolic diseases relating to death and disability in Kuwait,  Qatar and Oman – and second on the list in Bahrain.

In Britain, heart disease, lung cancer and Alzheimer’s remain among the leading causes of death, and people there are spending more time suffering from health problems.

The UK is expected to spend $421.4 billion on healthcare by 2040, up from $239.3 billion in 2014.

And development assistance for health is talking about the financial aid given to governments to support social, environmental development of developing countries.

 

Profile

Company name: Marefa Digital

Based: Dubai Multi Commodities Centre

Number of employees: seven

Sector: e-learning

Funding stage: Pre-seed funding of Dh1.5m in 2017 and an initial seed round of Dh2m in 2019

Investors: Friends and family 

Benefits of first-time home buyers' scheme
  • Priority access to new homes from participating developers
  • Discounts on sales price of off-plan units
  • Flexible payment plans from developers
  • Mortgages with better interest rates, faster approval times and reduced fees
  • DLD registration fee can be paid through banks or credit cards at zero interest rates
Ticket prices

General admission Dh295 (under-three free)

Buy a four-person Family & Friends ticket and pay for only three tickets, so the fourth family member is free

Buy tickets at: wbworldabudhabi.com/en/tickets

Blackpink World Tour [Born Pink] In Cinemas

Starring: Rose, Jisoo, Jennie, Lisa

Directors: Min Geun, Oh Yoon-Dong

Rating: 3/5

The Sand Castle

Director: Matty Brown

Stars: Nadine Labaki, Ziad Bakri, Zain Al Rafeea, Riman Al Rafeea

Rating: 2.5/5

UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
How to increase your savings
  • Have a plan for your savings.
  • Decide on your emergency fund target and once that's achieved, assign your savings to another financial goal such as saving for a house or investing for retirement.
  • Decide on a financial goal that is important to you and put your savings to work for you.
  • It's important to have a purpose for your savings as it helps to keep you motivated to continue while also reducing the temptation to spend your savings. 

- Carol Glynn, founder of Conscious Finance Coaching

 

 

Labour dispute

The insured employee may still file an ILOE claim even if a labour dispute is ongoing post termination, but the insurer may suspend or reject payment, until the courts resolve the dispute, especially if the reason for termination is contested. The outcome of the labour court proceedings can directly affect eligibility.


- Abdullah Ishnaneh, Partner, BSA Law 

Updated: July 04, 2023, 5:14 PM`