There are always limits to freedom of speech. Those limits vary depending on the traditions of different nations and legal systems and perhaps on political circumstances, too.
Back in 1919, the American jurist Oliver Wendell Holmes famously noted one limitation by arguing that no one has the freedom to yell out “fire” wrongly in a crowded theatre. It could lead to panic and potentially the loss of life. America’s First Amendment nevertheless is a landmark, saying that “Congress shall make no law …. abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances”.
Yet, the Holmes analogy – qualifying when freedom of speech can be abused – has been relied upon in hundreds of American constitutional cases for obvious reasons.
In the UK, the sense of freedom of speech remains strong but – unlike the American habit of spelling things out in a written constitution – the British remain somewhat vague about what such freedom entails and where it must be limited.
That vagueness illuminates a bitter row right now about the treatment and sentencing of a convicted British criminal and her inflammatory tweets. The Lucy Connolly case touches on the political faultlines in the UK that have opened up over migration, race and legitimate – or inflammatory – political debate.
Connolly is a childminder from Northampton. Last year, a deranged young man stabbed three young girls to death at a Taylor Swift-themed dance class in Southport. This was one of the most appalling crimes anyone can imagine. On social media, rumours started that the killer was an asylum seeker. Connolly tweeted that she wanted “mass deportation now” and suggested setting fire “to all the [expletive] hotels full of the [expletive] for all I care … if that makes me a racist so be it”.
She then deleted the tweet a few hours later. Anti-migrant riots and other disturbances followed the killings and led to a police crackdown, with Connolly among those arrested. She was charged, pleaded guilty to inciting racial hatred, then sentenced to 31 months in jail. This was a prison sentence longer than the sentences imposed on some of the rioters.
It is obviously possible to be appalled about Connolly’s inflammatory tweet and also to conclude that such a long jail sentence was very severe for the crime that she admitted. The Connolly case has, however, opened up not just a freedom of speech debate but also the idea among some on the right and far right of politics and in sections of the media that she is some kind of free speech martyr. She isn’t. Her tweet was nasty, inflammatory and part of a pattern. She had previously posted about people from Somalia along with a vomit emoji.
The Reform UK party leader, Nigel Farage, with his unerring sense of how to make news, is said to want to take Connolly to the US to appear before Congress. Presumably, this is to suggest that the UK has become some kind of anti-freedom of speech nation. It hasn’t. Nonetheless, the Connolly case is revelatory about the divisions in British society.
Lucy Connolly's tweet was nasty, inflammatory and part of a pattern
Opinion polls show Reform up to 28 per cent of the vote while the governing Labour party is at 20 per cent and the Conservatives and other parties trail behind those figures. Mr Farage is rarely out of the news. His genius is to point to real or not-so-real problems in British society and magnify them to his own advantage. Recently he’s been talking about deporting hundreds of thousands of irregular migrants to some unnamed foreign destination.
The rise of Reform, the Connolly case and the demonstrations at hotels used by migrants awaiting processing have led to a degree of panic in the Labour and Conservative parties. But perhaps, we all need to do that most difficult of tasks and to be calm and think.
August is known to British journalists as the “silly season”. Now in September, politics and journalism tend to return to more sober matters ahead of October’s party conferences. Second, Reform polling at 28 per cent may be a shock, but that means 72 per cent of British people are not planning to vote for Mr Farage. He’s loved by a significant group but loathed by many more. Third, a general election probably will not happen until 2029. The Farage genius in making news headlines, along with attempts to pretend that Connolly is a free speech martyr, will not solve Britain’s complex difficulties over migration.
As for the right to freedom of speech, since Mr Farage and his cohorts are on television and newspaper front pages more often than any other British political personality or party, we can probably agree that his views are far from being censored.
Mr Farage’s choice to defend someone who made inflammatory remarks about migration is, however, interesting. It’s not quite yelling “fire” in a crowded theatre, but it may sound like agreeing with those who like to stoke the flames of fear.
How much do leading UAE’s UK curriculum schools charge for Year 6?
- Nord Anglia International School (Dubai) – Dh85,032
- Kings School Al Barsha (Dubai) – Dh71,905
- Brighton College Abu Dhabi - Dh68,560
- Jumeirah English Speaking School (Dubai) – Dh59,728
- Gems Wellington International School – Dubai Branch – Dh58,488
- The British School Al Khubairat (Abu Dhabi) - Dh54,170
- Dubai English Speaking School – Dh51,269
*Annual tuition fees covering the 2024/2025 academic year
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Benefits of first-time home buyers' scheme
- Priority access to new homes from participating developers
- Discounts on sales price of off-plan units
- Flexible payment plans from developers
- Mortgages with better interest rates, faster approval times and reduced fees
- DLD registration fee can be paid through banks or credit cards at zero interest rates
UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
The five pillars of Islam
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
The years Ramadan fell in May
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Mohammed bin Zayed Majlis
Farage on Muslim Brotherhood
Nigel Farage told Reform's annual conference that the party will proscribe the Muslim Brotherhood if he becomes Prime Minister.
"We will stop dangerous organisations with links to terrorism operating in our country," he said. "Quite why we've been so gutless about this – both Labour and Conservative – I don't know.
“All across the Middle East, countries have banned and proscribed the Muslim Brotherhood as a dangerous organisation. We will do the very same.”
It is 10 years since a ground-breaking report into the Muslim Brotherhood by Sir John Jenkins.
Among the former diplomat's findings was an assessment that “the use of extreme violence in the pursuit of the perfect Islamic society” has “never been institutionally disowned” by the movement.
The prime minister at the time, David Cameron, who commissioned the report, said membership or association with the Muslim Brotherhood was a "possible indicator of extremism" but it would not be banned.
More coverage from the Future Forum
More from Neighbourhood Watch:
Zayed Sustainability Prize
UK's plans to cut net migration
Under the UK government’s proposals, migrants will have to spend 10 years in the UK before being able to apply for citizenship.
Skilled worker visas will require a university degree, and there will be tighter restrictions on recruitment for jobs with skills shortages.
But what are described as "high-contributing" individuals such as doctors and nurses could be fast-tracked through the system.
Language requirements will be increased for all immigration routes to ensure a higher level of English.
Rules will also be laid out for adult dependants, meaning they will have to demonstrate a basic understanding of the language.
The plans also call for stricter tests for colleges and universities offering places to foreign students and a reduction in the time graduates can remain in the UK after their studies from two years to 18 months.
Killing of Qassem Suleimani
More on Quran memorisation:
UAE squad
Humaira Tasneem (c), Chamani Senevirathne (vc), Subha Srinivasan, NIsha Ali, Udeni Kuruppuarachchi, Chaya Mughal, Roopa Nagraj, Esha Oza, Ishani Senevirathne, Heena Hotchandani, Keveesha Kumari, Judith Cleetus, Chavi Bhatt, Namita D’Souza.
The specs: Rolls-Royce Cullinan
Price, base: Dh1 million (estimate)
Engine: 6.75-litre twin-turbo V12
Transmission: Eight-speed automatic
Power: 563hp @ 5,000rpm
Torque: 850Nm @ 1,600rpm
Fuel economy, combined: 15L / 100km
DIVINE%20INTERVENTOIN
%3Cp%3EStarring%3A%20Elia%20Suleiman%2C%20Manal%20Khader%2C%20Amer%20Daher%3C%2Fp%3E%0A%3Cp%3EDirector%3A%20Elia%20Suleiman%3C%2Fp%3E%0A%3Cp%3ERating%3A%204.5%2F5%3C%2Fp%3E%0A
Zayed Sustainability Prize
Martin Sabbagh profile
Job: CEO JCDecaux Middle East
In the role: Since January 2015
Lives: In the UAE
Background: M&A, investment banking
Studied: Corporate finance
Apple%20Mac%20through%20the%20years
%3Cp%3E1984%20-%20Apple%20unveiled%20the%20Macintosh%20on%20January%2024%3Cbr%3E1985%20-%20Steve%20Jobs%20departed%20from%20Apple%20and%20established%20NeXT%3Cbr%3E1986%20-%20Apple%20introduced%20the%20Macintosh%20Plus%2C%20featuring%20enhanced%20memory%3Cbr%3E1987%20-%20Apple%20launched%20the%20Macintosh%20II%2C%20equipped%20with%20colour%20capabilities%3Cbr%3E1989%20-%20The%20widely%20acclaimed%20Macintosh%20SE%2F30%20made%20its%20debut%3Cbr%3E1994%20-%20Apple%20presented%20the%20Power%20Macintosh%3Cbr%3E1996%20-%20The%20Macintosh%20System%20Software%20OS%20underwent%20a%20rebranding%20as%20Mac%20OS%3Cbr%3E2001%20-%20Apple%20introduced%20Mac%20OS%20X%2C%20marrying%20Unix%20stability%20with%20a%20user-friendly%20interface%3Cbr%3E2006%20-%20Apple%20adopted%20Intel%20processors%20in%20MacBook%20Pro%20laptops%3Cbr%3E2008%20-%20Apple%20introduced%20the%20MacBook%20Air%2C%20a%20lightweight%20laptop%3Cbr%3E2012%20-%20Apple%20launched%20the%20MacBook%20Pro%20with%20a%20retina%20display%3Cbr%3E2016%20-%20The%20Mac%20operating%20system%20underwent%20rebranding%20as%20macOS%3Cbr%3E2020%20-%20Apple%20introduced%20the%20M1%20chip%20for%20Macs%2C%20combining%20high%20performance%20and%20energy%20efficiency%3Cbr%3E2022%20-%20The%20M2%20chip%20was%20announced%3Cbr%3E2023%20-The%20M3%20line-up%20of%20chip%20was%20announced%20to%20improve%20performance%20and%20add%20new%20capabilities%20for%20Mac.%3C%2Fp%3E%0A
Zayed Sustainability Prize
More from Neighbourhood Watch:
Evacuations to France hit by controversy
- Over 500 Gazans have been evacuated to France since November 2023
- Evacuations were paused after a student already in France posted anti-Semitic content and was subsequently expelled to Qatar
- The Foreign Ministry launched a review to determine how authorities failed to detect the posts before her entry
- Artists and researchers fall under a programme called Pause that began in 2017
- It has benefited more than 700 people from 44 countries, including Syria, Turkey, Iran, and Sudan
- Since the start of the Gaza war, it has also included 45 Gazan beneficiaries
- Unlike students, they are allowed to bring their families to France
The years Ramadan fell in May
The five pillars of Islam
1. Fasting
2. Prayer
3. Hajj
4. Shahada
5. Zakat
