Omar Al-Ubaydli is a Bahraini economist and a columnist for The National
January 08, 2025
Many around the world are keen to help Syrians as their country enters a post-Baathism era. There is much talk of foreign aid, but its demonstrable effectiveness has always been highly contentious. A potentially more productive area of focus could be to help make it easier for Syrians to work abroad in markets where their skills are needed, and for them to send money back home, while their country’s economy rebuilds.
Decades of mismanagement and war-induced destruction have left Syria’s economy in ruins. Fortunately, Syria remains historically rich in human capital, offering its citizens plenty of light at the end of the dark tunnel they are currently traversing. People around the world are rightly confident that – with the right investment and government oversight – the country can regain its status as a Middle Eastern commercial and intellectual hub.
Tempering this optimism is the fact that the world’s recent track record in helping struggling countries fulfil their economic potential can be euphemistically described as “mixed”. The default option is foreign aid, which involves richer countries providing grants to poorer ones. The policy origins of this option are a geopolitical version of someone helping their embattled friend by giving them a financial helping hand until they get back on their feet.
But at the country level, this tends to go awry for several reasons, chief among them being the receiving country’s government either lacking the capacity – or, in the case of corruption, the will – to distribute the grant in an economically productive manner. This has often led to two alternative approaches: direct grants to those in need that bypass the government, or conditional aid that requires the government to demonstrate sufficient levels of competence and integrity.
Unfortunately, a more depressing factor in accounting for the ineffectiveness of foreign aid in any guise is that the interests of the assisting government are sometimes poorly aligned with those of the targeted recipients. Sometimes, a donor’s strategic priority is using foreign aid to favourably influence local politics more than to put the country on the road towards economic independence and prosperity. The most obvious illustration is the USSR’s disastrous export of communism in Eastern Europe during the Cold War, but its western adversaries also have an extensive rap sheet when it comes to using financial aid in Latin America and the Middle East.
Sometimes, a donor’s strategic priority is using foreign aid to favourably influence local politics
Equally concerning is the fact that even a well-intentioned donor country often trips up because the civil servants in charge of aid disbursement are so far removed from the on-the-ground problems they are seeking to solve that they end up making poor allocation decisions. The international development landscape is full of white elephant projects that invoke a combination of ridicule and frustration from the hapless “beneficiaries” left wondering what might have been had they been properly consulted regarding their needs.
Fortunately, a highly effective but under-the-radar alternative to foreign aid has been operating for decades, taking the form of remittances from migrant workers. In countries such as Bangladesh and India – both of which have been rapidly ascending the living standards ladder – the capital inflows from their citizens working abroad and remitting income home have played a pivotal role in economic development.
Remittances’ superiority to government-mediated foreign aid lies in several factors, the most important of which is that the person sending the money – the expatriate worker – is intimately familiar with the needs of the person receiving it – their family. None of it gets siphoned off by corrupt civil servants or non-governmental organisations charging overhead, allowing it to be allocated to educational investments for children, housing upgrades for the family, startup capital for microenterprises or simply covering critical living expenses. Moreover, it is precisely tailored to the beneficiary’s needs, rather than being some crude, country-level program.
Today, increasing numbers of Bangladeshis and Indians are shunning economic migration in favour of working in their home countries because good government policy supported by decades of remittances have created attractive domestic economic opportunities. Scholars struggle to find comparable success stories in the foreign aid realm beyond the post-Second World War Marshall Plan, which is more than 75 years old.
The signing of the Bretton Woods Agreements in July 1944. The Bretton Woods era and the Marshall Plan set the stage for the post-Second World War economic order. Getty Images
An added benefit of remittances is that they constitute a more dignified form of assistance than handouts. The remitter justifiably feels that they earned the income they are sending home, rather than suffering the indignity of being viewed as a recipient of a charitable donation.
Syrians – like people from every country in the world – want to live in their home country if suitable economic opportunities exist therein. While the Syrian government tackles the immense task of creating those opportunities, during a transitional period, prospective donor countries may do more good by considering favouring Syrians in their guest worker programmes and other temporary employment regimes. It is morally incumbent upon those who favour foreign aid to study the history of international development assistance before insisting on such an approach. As the economist Milton Friedman once quipped: “One of the great mistakes is to judge policies and programs by their intentions rather than their results.”
box
COMPANY PROFILE
Company name: Letstango.com
Started: June 2013
Founder: Alex Tchablakian
Based: Dubai
Industry: e-commerce
Initial investment: Dh10 million
Investors: Self-funded
Total customers: 300,000 unique customers every month
Tottenham's 10 biggest transfers (according to transfermarkt.com):
1). Moussa Sissokho - Newcastle United - £30 million (Dh143m): Flop
2). Roberto Soldado - Valencia - £25m: Flop
3). Erik Lamela - Roma - £25m: Jury still out
4). Son Heung-min - Bayer Leverkusen - £25m: Success
5pm: Mohamed Yousuf Naghi Motors Cup (Turf), 5.35pm: 1351 Cup (T), 6.10pm: Longines Turf Handicap (T), 6.45pm: Obaiya Arabian Classic for Purebred Arabians (Dirt), 7.30pm: Jockey Club Handicap (D), 8.10pm: Samba Saudi Derby (D), 8.50pm: Saudia Sprint (D), 9.40pm: Saudi Cup (D)
Specs
Engine: Duel electric motors Power: 659hp Torque: 1075Nm On sale: Available for pre-order now Price: On request
The specs
Engine: 3.0-litre six-cylinder turbo
Power: 398hp from 5,250rpm
Torque: 580Nm at 1,900-4,800rpm
Transmission: Eight-speed auto
Fuel economy, combined: 6.5L/100km
On sale: December
Price: From Dh330,000 (estimate)
The specs
Engine: 3.9-litre twin-turbo V8 Power: 620hp from 5,750-7,500rpm Torque: 760Nm from 3,000-5,750rpm Transmission: Eight-speed dual-clutch auto On sale: Now Price: From Dh1.05 million ($286,000)
French business
France has organised a delegation of leading businesses to travel to Syria. The group was led by French shipping giant CMA CGM, which struck a 30-year contract in May with the Syrian government to develop and run Latakia port. Also present were water and waste management company Suez, defence multinational Thales, and Ellipse Group, which is currently looking into rehabilitating Syrian hospitals.
2.0
Director: S Shankar
Producer: Lyca Productions; presented by Dharma Films
Engine: 4.0-litre V8 twin-turbocharged and three electric motors
Power: Combined output 920hp
Torque: 730Nm at 4,000-7,000rpm
Transmission: 8-speed dual-clutch automatic
Fuel consumption: 11.2L/100km
On sale: Now, deliveries expected later in 2025
Price: expected to start at Dh1,432,000
Essentials
The flights Emirates and Etihad fly direct from the UAE to Los Angeles, from Dh4,975 return, including taxes. The flight time is 16 hours. Alaska Airlines, United Airlines,Delta Air Lines, Aeromexico and Southwest all fly direct from Los Angeles to San Jose del Cabo from Dh1,243 return, including taxes. The flight time is two-and-a-half hours.
The trip Lindblad Expeditions National Geographic’s eight-day Whales Wilderness itinerary costs from US$6,190 (Dh22,736) per person, twin share, including meals, accommodation and excursions, with departures in March and April 2018.
The five pillars of Islam
1. Fasting
2. Prayer
3. Hajj
4. Shahada
5. Zakat
Benefits of first-time home buyers' scheme
Priority access to new homes from participating developers
Discounts on sales price of off-plan units
Flexible payment plans from developers
Mortgages with better interest rates, faster approval times and reduced fees
DLD registration fee can be paid through banks or credit cards at zero interest rates
Name: Thndr Started: 2019 Co-founders: Ahmad Hammouda and Seif Amr Sector: FinTech Headquarters: Egypt UAE base: Hub71, Abu Dhabi Current number of staff: More than 150 Funds raised: $22 million
Community volunteers have swung into action delivering food packages and toiletries to the men.
When provisions are distributed, the men line up in long queues for packets of rice, flour, sugar, salt, pulses, milk, biscuits, shaving kits, soap and telecom cards.
Volunteers from St Mary’s Catholic Church said some workers came to the church to pray for their families and ask for assistance.
Boxes packed with essential food items were distributed to workers in the Dubai Investments Park and Ras Al Khaimah camps last week. Workers at the Sonapur camp asked for Dh1,600 towards their gas bill.
“Especially in this year of tolerance we consider ourselves privileged to be able to lend a helping hand to our needy brothers in the Actco camp," Father Lennie Connully, parish priest of St Mary’s.
Workers spoke of their helplessness, seeing children’s marriages cancelled because of lack of money going home. Others told of their misery of being unable to return home when a parent died.
“More than daily food, they are worried about not sending money home for their family,” said Kusum Dutta, a volunteer who works with the Indian consulate.
