Israel's slide into reactionary politics spells the end of Oslo


  • English
  • Arabic

Like the Norwegian Blue parrot in the legendary Monty Python skit, the Oslo peace process is not resting, tired out after a long squawk; the peace process, as we've come to know it, is dead. It has ceased to be. The question facing all sides of the Middle East equation now is what will replace it.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's recent speech in Washington made clear that he simply has no intention of yielding voluntarily to Palestinian statehood based on the terms of the international consensus. And the speech's rapturous reception, both on Capitol Hill and back home in Israel, makes clear that Mr Netanyahu speaks for a sustainable consensus within Israel and within its most important foreign backer.

Like Mr Netanyahu himself, a majority of Israelis say they support a two-state solution - but when it comes to defining what that means, they support Mr Netanyahu's position that it's unthinkable for Israel to cede control of much of the territory it currently occupies outside of its 1967 borders.

There's nothing new about Mr Netanyahu rejecting the international consensus on a two-state solution: the prime minister built his political career out of fighting against Oslo, and regained the leadership of the Likud Party by opposing then prime minister Ariel Sharon's withdrawal from Gaza. What's changed, notes the former Israeli peace negotiator Daniel Levy, is that the Israeli mainstream has moved closer to Netanyahu's position.

Levy, writing in Foreign Affairs, notes that the party of Yitzhak Rabin and the Oslo process has been marginalised in Israeli politics. "The rump Zionist left-of-centre in Israel's Knesset has shrivelled from 43 members in 1996 to just 11 today," he notes. The two largest political parties besides Likud - Tzipi Livni's Kadima and Avigdor Lieberman's Yisrael Beiteinu - are both spin-offs of Likud.

Levy notes also that the social profile of Israeli society has changed profoundly over the past 20 years, with the rising influence of right-wing religious nationalists and Russian elements making the Israel of Yitzhak Rabin but a memory.

The ultra-Orthodox population has grown from 3 per cent to 10 per cent of Israeli society, and is the fastest growing Jewish population. Already close to one in three Israeli children is enrolled in the separate school systems run by the religious Shas party - the madrasas of religious nationalism in Israel. And, of course, a further 20 per cent of Israeli Jews are Russian immigrants who arrived after the Soviet collapse, and who largely back the parties of the authoritarian anti-Arab right.

Mr Netanyahu, in his speech to Congress, put the number of settlers currently living on territory occupied by Israel in 1967 at 650,000 - that's more than double the settler population in 1996. The settlers have become a powerful political bloc in the government, and an even more significant influence in the military, where they often form the committed core of combat units. It's unlikely that any Israeli government will test the loyalty of this force by ordering them to forcibly evacuate settlements on any mass scale.

Robert Malley and Hussein Agha, two veterans of the Oslo process and among its most astute observers, wrote in January: "Almost two decades after the peace process was launched, little remains of the foundational principle that each side has something of value to which the other aspires and thus something it can offer in exchange for what it wants." While it continues to occupy Palestinian land and control Palestinian lives, there's little downside for the Israelis in a status quo that "although not as satisfactory as Israelis would like ... is not as unpleasant as their adversaries would wish".

The Palestinian leadership had hoped that the US would press Israel to accept a just solution to the conflict, but the spectacle of Mr Netanyahu rebuking Mr Obama before his own legislature and being cheered for it demonstrated just how decisively Israel has won the battle for America's monogamous affection.

President Mahmoud Abbas has been forced, by two decades of disappointment and by mounting pressure from below, to break with Washington and pursue an independent path, which - whatever his intentions - will inaugurate a new chapter in Palestinian history whose outlines, cast of characters and outcome have not yet been written.

It's unlikely that the ageing and despondent Mr Abbas will be at the helm when the new chapter concludes. It promises to be a long one, after all, and of necessity goes beyond Mr Abbas's comfort zone of negotiations.

Palestinian politics today runs the gamut from salafist jihadis to activists waging unarmed mass struggle in a spirit similar to the Arab Spring; from competing currents within Hamas to technocrats running the machinery of the Palestinian Authority.

While the UN bid for recognition of statehood may be the centrepiece of the break with Washington, it will, of necessity, force Palestinian leaders to answer strategic questions on how they will proceed if thwarted, or affirmed, at the UN. How would they muster the leverage to persuade Israel to end its occupation? Will a new state supplant the PLO as the authority that speaks for Palestinians, and if so, how would it represent the refugees living outside its territory? How would it prevent terror attacks on a neighbouring UN member state? The list is long and complicated.

But the fact that these questions are even on the table indicates the profound change under way in the Israeli-Palestinian equation. For the first time in more than a decade, Palestinian politics has become unpredictable, entering a moment replete with perils - and with possibilities. Don't expect the region's most intractable conflict to be resolved any time soon. But it would be unwise also to expect that when the conflict is resolved, it will be on the basis of a script written two decades ago.

Tony Karon is an analyst based in New York. Follow him on Twitter @TonyKaron

UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Dubai Bling season three

Cast: Loujain Adada, Zeina Khoury, Farhana Bodi, Ebraheem Al Samadi, Mona Kattan, and couples Safa & Fahad Siddiqui and DJ Bliss & Danya Mohammed 

Rating: 1/5

Biog

Mr Kandhari is legally authorised to conduct marriages in the gurdwara

He has officiated weddings of Sikhs and people of different faiths from Malaysia, Sri Lanka, Russia, the US and Canada

Father of two sons, grandfather of six

Plays golf once a week

Enjoys trying new holiday destinations with his wife and family

Walks for an hour every morning

Completed a Bachelor of Commerce degree in Loyola College, Chennai, India

2019 is a milestone because he completes 50 years in business

 

Starring: Jamie Foxx, Angela Bassett, Tina Fey

Directed by: Pete Doctor

Rating: 4 stars

'Young girls thinking of big ideas'

Words come easy for aspiring writer Afra Al Muhairb. The business side of books, on the other hand, is entirely foreign to the 16-year-old Emirati. So, she followed her father’s advice and enroled in the Abu Dhabi Education Council’s summer entrepreneurship course at Abu Dhabi University hoping to pick up a few new skills.

“Most of us have this dream of opening a business,” said Afra, referring to her peers are “young girls thinking of big ideas.”

In the three-week class, pupils are challenged to come up with a business and develop an operational and marketing plan to support their idea. But, the learning goes far beyond sales and branding, said teacher Sonia Elhaj.

“It’s not only about starting up a business, it’s all the meta skills that goes with it -- building self confidence, communication,” said Ms Elhaj. “It’s a way to coach them and to harness ideas and to allow them to be creative. They are really hungry to do this and be heard. They are so happy to be actually doing something, to be engaged in creating something new, not only sitting and listening and getting new information and new knowledge. Now they are applying that knowledge.”

Afra’s team decided to focus their business idea on a restaurant modelled after the Leaning Tower of Pisa. Each level would have a different international cuisine and all the meat would be halal. The pupils thought of this after discussing a common problem they face when travelling abroad.

“Sometimes we find the struggle of finding halal food, so we just eat fish and cheese, so it’s hard for us to spend 20 days with fish and cheese,” said Afra. “So we made this tower so every person who comes – from Africa, from America – they will find the right food to eat.”

rpennington@thenational.ae

Global state-owned investor ranking by size

1.

United States

2.

China

3.

UAE

4.

Japan

5

Norway

6.

Canada

7.

Singapore

8.

Australia

9.

Saudi Arabia

10.

South Korea

Key facilities
  • Olympic-size swimming pool with a split bulkhead for multi-use configurations, including water polo and 50m/25m training lanes
  • Premier League-standard football pitch
  • 400m Olympic running track
  • NBA-spec basketball court with auditorium
  • 600-seat auditorium
  • Spaces for historical and cultural exploration
  • An elevated football field that doubles as a helipad
  • Specialist robotics and science laboratories
  • AR and VR-enabled learning centres
  • Disruption Lab and Research Centre for developing entrepreneurial skills