A federal judge is set to hear closing arguments on Friday before determining how he will punish Google for illegally maintaining a search engine monopoly.
The case, brought by the US government, could throw Google's expansion plans into turmoil just as it looks to strengthen its artificial intelligence offerings.
District Judge Amit Mehta last year sided with the US Justice Department and ruled that Alphabet-owned Google had been illegally exploiting its dominance in the search sector to stifle competition, ultimately harming consumers with less choice.
Last month, the trial moved into a second phase, with Mr Mehta listening to technology executives, economists and regulatory experts as he considers what penalty he will levy against Google.
His decision could be one of the most consequential in technology regulation since 1982, when the Department of Justice broke up AT&T's monopoly through its Bell telephone system. Another landmark case came in 2000 when a judge found that Microsoft breached antitrust laws by engaging in predatory practices.
The Justice Department wants Mr Mehta to enact far-reaching penalties that would be a warning to other companies.
Prosecutors want Google to divest its popular Chrome browser from its portfolio, and it wants the tech giant to share coveted search data with competitors.
The department also wants to end the lucrative deals arranged by Google where it pays companies such as Samsung and Apple to make Google's search tool the default option on devices.
Mark MacCarthy, a senior fellow at the Institute for Technology Law and Policy at Georgetown University in Washington, has studied antitrust policy for several decades. He said Google’s ubiquitous presence presents the judge with a unique challenge.
Mr MacCarthy voiced concerns that a court-ordered requirement for Google to share users' search data could see companies exploit that information without people's consent.
Forcing Google to share data "would require unprecedented co-operation among the courts involved", he said. “My view is that this would be better done by a new digital regulatory agency.”
Google has been pushing its own proposed remedies. These are far lighter than those proposed by the department, including a solution that would give users the ability to change their default search provider at least every 12 months.
“Our proposal allows browsers to continue to offer Google Search to their users and earn revenue from that partnership … but it also provides them with additional flexibility,” Google said, adding that it would give options to hardware sellers to make deals with other search engines.
“Browser companies like Apple and Mozilla should continue to have the freedom to do deals with whatever search engine they think is best for their users.”
Google has also proposed what it described as a “robust mechanism” to ensure that it would comply with the proposed remedy.
The case playing out in Washington is not the only legal battle Google is fighting. The tech giant is appealing against part of a recent ruling that found it unfairly used its internet advertising dominance and crushed competitors.
In that case, both Google and the government are trying to shape what remedy will ultimately be decided.
The worst-case scenario for Google in that case could be that it is forced to spin off its advertising technology division, which would mean the loss of a significant amount of revenue for the search engine.
Perhaps more importantly, whatever ensues could have ripple effects across the technology ecosystem revolving around Google.
Eric Mulheim, chief financial officer of Mozilla, maker of the Firefox web browser, spoke about that shortly after testifying in the antitrust remedy trial.
“We believe the court should ensure that small and independent browsers are not harmed in any final remedies,” Mr Mulheim said, referring to Mozilla's paid partnership with Google that could be threatened by what the judge decides.
“Without this, we risk trading one monopoly for another, and the vibrant, people-first web we’ve spent decades fighting for could begin to fade."
In a separate court filing, Mozilla pushed for a “more tailored” approach to whatever remedies are decided on, that will not affect independent web browsers.
Even with so much legal scrutiny, in terms of influence, market share and revenue, Google is still a force to be reckoned with. To regulators, that is the whole point, and the legal walls seem to be closing in.
On Friday, however, both Google and the department have one more chance to influence the final decision as Mr Mehta considers closing arguments.
Benefits of first-time home buyers' scheme
- Priority access to new homes from participating developers
- Discounts on sales price of off-plan units
- Flexible payment plans from developers
- Mortgages with better interest rates, faster approval times and reduced fees
- DLD registration fee can be paid through banks or credit cards at zero interest rates
UAE currency: the story behind the money in your pockets
Scoreline
Arsenal 0 Manchester City 3
- Agüero 18'
- Kompany 58'
- Silva 65'
MATCH INFO
Fixture: Ukraine v Portugal, Monday, 10.45pm (UAE)
TV: BeIN Sports
MATCH INFO
Syria v Australia
2018 World Cup qualifying: Asia fourth round play-off first leg
Venue: Hang Jebat Stadium (Malacca, Malayisa)
Kick-off: Thursday, 4.30pm (UAE)
Watch: beIN Sports HD
* Second leg in Australia scheduled for October 10
How has net migration to UK changed?
The figure was broadly flat immediately before the Covid-19 pandemic, standing at 216,000 in the year to June 2018 and 224,000 in the year to June 2019.
It then dropped to an estimated 111,000 in the year to June 2020 when restrictions introduced during the pandemic limited travel and movement.
The total rose to 254,000 in the year to June 2021, followed by steep jumps to 634,000 in the year to June 2022 and 906,000 in the year to June 2023.
The latest available figure of 728,000 for the 12 months to June 2024 suggests levels are starting to decrease.
More from Neighbourhood Watch:
David Haye record
Total fights: 32
Wins: 28
Wins by KO: 26
Losses: 4
MATCH INFO
Europa League final
Who: Marseille v Atletico Madrid
Where: Parc OL, Lyon, France
When: Wednesday, 10.45pm kick off (UAE)
TV: BeIN Sports
The specs
Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl turbo
Power: 261hp at 5,500rpm
Torque: 405Nm at 1,750-3,500rpm
Transmission: 9-speed auto
Fuel consumption: 6.9L/100km
On sale: Now
Price: From Dh117,059
AI traffic lights to ease congestion at seven points to Sheikh Zayed bin Sultan Street
The seven points are:
Shakhbout bin Sultan Street
Dhafeer Street
Hadbat Al Ghubainah Street (outbound)
Salama bint Butti Street
Al Dhafra Street
Rabdan Street
Umm Yifina Street exit (inbound)
More from Neighbourhood Watch
PROFILE OF HALAN
Started: November 2017
Founders: Mounir Nakhla, Ahmed Mohsen and Mohamed Aboulnaga
Based: Cairo, Egypt
Sector: transport and logistics
Size: 150 employees
Investment: approximately $8 million
Investors include: Singapore’s Battery Road Digital Holdings, Egypt’s Algebra Ventures, Uber co-founder and former CTO Oscar Salazar
What sanctions would be reimposed?
Under ‘snapback’, measures imposed on Iran by the UN Security Council in six resolutions would be restored, including:
- An arms embargo
- A ban on uranium enrichment and reprocessing
- A ban on launches and other activities with ballistic missiles capable of delivering nuclear weapons, as well as ballistic missile technology transfer and technical assistance
- A targeted global asset freeze and travel ban on Iranian individuals and entities
- Authorisation for countries to inspect Iran Air Cargo and Islamic Republic of Iran Shipping Lines cargoes for banned goods
Results:
6.30pm: Handicap | US$135,000 (Dirt) | 1,400 metres
Winner: Rodaini, Connor Beasley (jockey), Ahmad bin Harmash (trainer)
7.05pm: Handicap | $135,000 (Turf) | 1,200m
Winner: Ekhtiyaar, Jim Crowley, Doug Watson
7.40pm: Dubai Millennium Stakes | Group 3 | $200,000 (T) | 2,000m
Winner: Spotify, James Doyle, Charlie Appleby
8.15pm: UAE Oakes | Group 3 | $250,000 (D) | 1,900m
Winner: Divine Image, William Buick, Charlie Appleby
8.50pm: Zabeel Mile | Group 2 | $250,000 (T) | 1,600m
Winner: Mythical Image, William Buick, Charlie Appleby
9.20pm: Handicap | $135,000 (T) | 1,600m
Winner: Major Partnership, Kevin Stott, Saeed bin Suroor
The specs
Engine: 3.0-litre six-cylinder turbo
Power: 398hp from 5,250rpm
Torque: 580Nm at 1,900-4,800rpm
Transmission: Eight-speed auto
Fuel economy, combined: 6.5L/100km
On sale: December
Price: From Dh330,000 (estimate)
Three tips from La Perle's performers
1 The kind of water athletes drink is important. Gwilym Hooson, a 28-year-old British performer who is currently recovering from knee surgery, found that out when the company was still in Studio City, training for 12 hours a day. “The physio team was like: ‘Why is everyone getting cramps?’ And then they realised we had to add salt and sugar to the water,” he says.
2 A little chocolate is a good thing. “It’s emergency energy,” says Craig Paul Smith, La Perle’s head coach and former Cirque du Soleil performer, gesturing to an almost-empty open box of mini chocolate bars on his desk backstage.
3 Take chances, says Young, who has worked all over the world, including most recently at Dragone’s show in China. “Every time we go out of our comfort zone, we learn a lot about ourselves,” she says.
Evacuations to France hit by controversy
- Over 500 Gazans have been evacuated to France since November 2023
- Evacuations were paused after a student already in France posted anti-Semitic content and was subsequently expelled to Qatar
- The Foreign Ministry launched a review to determine how authorities failed to detect the posts before her entry
- Artists and researchers fall under a programme called Pause that began in 2017
- It has benefited more than 700 people from 44 countries, including Syria, Turkey, Iran, and Sudan
- Since the start of the Gaza war, it has also included 45 Gazan beneficiaries
- Unlike students, they are allowed to bring their families to France
The five pillars of Islam
1. Fasting
2. Prayer
3. Hajj
4. Shahada
5. Zakat
AndhaDhun
Director: Sriram Raghavan
Producer: Matchbox Pictures, Viacom18
Cast: Ayushmann Khurrana, Tabu, Radhika Apte, Anil Dhawan
Rating: 3.5/5
LILO & STITCH
Starring: Sydney Elizebeth Agudong, Maia Kealoha, Chris Sanders
Director: Dean Fleischer Camp
Rating: 4.5/5
Sri Lanka's T20I squad
Thisara Perera (captain), Dilshan Munaweera, Danushka Gunathilaka, Sadeera Samarawickrama, Ashan Priyanjan, Mahela Udawatte, Dasun Shanaka, Sachith Pathirana, Vikum Sanjaya, Lahiru Gamage, Seekkuge Prasanna, Vishwa Fernando, Isuru Udana, Jeffrey Vandersay and Chathuranga de Silva.
Christopher Robin
Starring: Ewan McGregor, Haley Atwell, Jim Cummings, Peter Capaldi
Three stars
